Analyzing Aloy’s potential Super Smash Bros debut and what it reveals about PlayStation-Nintendo crossover strategies
The Growing Developer Wishlist for Smash Inclusion
The conversation around potential Super Smash Bros roster additions continues well beyond the conclusion of Ultimate’s DLC cycle. Developers across the industry regularly voice their aspirations to see their iconic characters join Nintendo’s celebrated fighting franchise. This trend highlights how Smash Bros has evolved beyond a simple Nintendo crossover into a barometer for gaming industry recognition and cross-platform collaboration.
Recent years have witnessed numerous public appeals from prominent development studios. Mortal Kombat creator Ed Boon has consistently advocated for Scorpion’s inclusion, while Ubisoft’s Mario + Rabbids creative director pushed for Rayman representation. Perhaps most notably, developers from 343 Industries have openly campaigned for Master Chief to “finish the fight” within Smash’s competitive arena. These public statements serve dual purposes: they gauge fan interest while potentially signaling to Nintendo which partnerships might be most enthusiastically received.
The strategic value of Smash inclusion extends beyond mere prestige. Characters introduced to the franchise typically experience measurable spikes in merchandise sales, digital downloads of their source games, and broader brand recognition. For third-party developers, securing a roster spot represents both commercial opportunity and creative validation within gaming’s most visible crossover platform.
Guerrilla Games’ Position on Aloy’s Potential Crossover
Tim Symons, franchise development lead producer at Guerrilla Games, recently addressed the possibility during an interview with Kotaku. When questioned about Aloy potentially joining Super Smash Bros following Horizon’s expansion to Nintendo Switch via Horizon Lego Adventures, Symons responded with measured optimism. “That’d be nice,” he stated, adding, “If you speak to Nintendo and they want to invite us let me know.”
This response carries significant implications for understanding current negotiation dynamics. Symons’ conditional phrasing—”if they want to invite us”—strongly suggests that no formal discussions have occurred between Nintendo, PlayStation, or Guerrilla Games regarding Aloy’s inclusion. Alternatively, such discussions might be happening at higher corporate levels without Symons’ direct involvement. The comment reflects the complex multilayer negotiations required for cross-platform character licensing, often involving publisher, developer, and platform holder approvals.
Practical consideration: When evaluating potential Smash candidates, Nintendo typically considers multiple factors beyond developer enthusiasm. These include character recognition across Nintendo’s primary demographics, gameplay translation potential, existing business relationships, and broader strategic partnerships. Aloy’s recent appearance on Nintendo Switch via the Lego spin-off establishes some precedent, but major first-party PlayStation characters historically face higher barriers to crossover inclusion.
Analyzing Aloy’s Combat Translation to Smash Mechanics
From a gameplay design perspective, Aloy presents compelling mechanics for adaptation to Super Smash Bros’ platform fighting systems. Her Horizon combat toolkit offers numerous possibilities for distinctive move sets that would differentiate her from existing roster members while maintaining competitive balance.
Key combat elements ripe for adaptation include:
Projectile Variety: Aloy’s arsenal includes multiple bow types with different arrow properties—hardpoint arrows for damage, fire arrows for damage-over-time effects, and tearblast arrows for shield-breaking potential. This could translate to neutral-special variations similar to Link’s arrow mechanics but with elemental effects.
Trap Deployment: Her tripcaster could function as a defensive area-control tool, creating temporary hazard zones on stage. This would introduce strategic positioning elements uncommon among current roster members.
Melee Combos: Aloy’s spear techniques from Horizon Forbidden West offer foundation for close-quarters combat chains. These could incorporate light/heavy attack variations with different launch properties and combo potential.
Override Abilities: While direct machine summoning might prove technically challenging, temporary buffs or assist attacks inspired by machine overrides could function as powerful limit-break style final smashes.
Common adaptation mistake to avoid: Overloading a character with too many situational tools that create balance issues. Successful Smash adaptations typically distill source material into 4-6 signature mechanics rather than attempting comprehensive representation.
The Current State of Super Smash Bros Development
Despite Ultimate’s DLC conclusion with Kingdom Hearts’ Sora, speculation about the franchise’s future continues unabated. Series creator Masahiro Sakurai has hinted at Nintendo’s ongoing work on a new Smash project, though whether this constitutes a fully original title or an enhanced “Ultimate Deluxe” edition remains uncertain. This ambiguity affects how developers approach potential inclusion discussions, as different development approaches might prioritize different types of roster additions.
Several factors currently cloud the franchise’s immediate future:
Hardware Transition: Nintendo’s next console generation will significantly influence Smash’s development timeline and technical capabilities. New hardware could enable more ambitious crossovers or different approaches to roster composition.
Licensing Complexities: Each third-party character requires renegotiation for new installations. This administrative burden might encourage Nintendo to pursue fewer but more significant crossover partnerships in future iterations.
Market Evolution: The gaming landscape has shifted since Ultimate’s release, with different franchises ascending in popularity. Future roster decisions will likely reflect contemporary gaming trends alongside historical significance.
Optimization tip for speculation: Focus on characters with established Nintendo presence through spin-offs, merchandise collaborations, or previous appearances. These existing business relationships often precede Smash inclusion.
Broader Implications for PlayStation-Nintendo Relations
Aloy’s potential inclusion represents more than individual character discussion—it signals possible evolution in platform holder relationships. Historically, first-party characters from competing consoles have appeared sparingly in Smash Bros, with Sega’s Sonic and Microsoft’s Banjo-Kazooie representing notable exceptions following specific corporate partnerships.
The landscape may be shifting with several developments:
Cross-Platform Expansion: PlayStation’s increased willingness to bring franchises to PC and other platforms suggests potential flexibility regarding Nintendo collaborations. However, core first-party titles remain strategically exclusive.
Media Synergy: Reports of Illumination pursuing a Super Smash Bros cinematic universe following The Mario Movie’s success could influence character selection. Film adaptations often prioritize widely recognizable characters with strong visual identities.
Anniversary Considerations: With Smash Bros approaching its 25th anniversary, Nintendo may pursue particularly significant additions to commemorate the milestone. A first-ever PlayStation character would certainly qualify as landmark inclusion.
Nothing has been formally confirmed regarding Aloy’s inclusion or the next Smash installment’s development. The franchise’s future remains closely tied to Nintendo’s next console unveiling and broader corporate strategy. Until official announcements emerge, developer enthusiasm like Symons’ comments will continue fueling speculation and community discussion about gaming’s ultimate crossover possibilities.
Dispatch devs comment on fate of Season 2 as Aaron Paul hopes for more
Monster Girl and Robot are bustin’ through to join Invincible VS’s growing character roster
All Borderlands games & spin-offs in order
No reproduction without permission：Games Guides Website » Guerrilla Games wants Horizon’s Aloy in the next Super Smash Bros Analyzing Aloy's potential Super Smash Bros debut and what it reveals about PlayStation-Nintendo crossover strategies